Go Model Pulling Tutorial

Objective and Overview

The objective of this tutorial is to demonstrate the use of simplfied representations of the protein chain, in this case Go-type models, to explore the unfolding of proteins via single molecule pulling experments.

This example utilizes the MMTSB Go Model Server to create a Go-type model from the relevant pdb file (1QJO.pdb) and then carries out pulling experiments, using the CHARMM afm module, via constant speed pulling. The protein is streched from two different points. First streching from the N- and C-termini is examined. Next the "experiments" are run by connecting the pulling point to the N-terminus and at residue 41, midway through the structure.

Very different streching profiles arise from these two different experiments. Moreover, the results from this simple model correlate very well with experiments and earlier calculations by Brockwell et al. [Brockwell et al., NSB, 10, 731 (2003)]

1QJO_M1.gif

Pulling geometry defines the mechanical resistance of a beta-sheet protein


This example uses CHARMM and the input file pull_GoModel.inp together with the files that came from the Go Model Server noted above, for the pdb fle 1QJO these are: GO_1qjo.Qdetails, GO_1qjo.Qlist, GO_1qjo.param, GO_1qjo.pdb, GO_1qjo.seq, GO_1qjo.top. You can download all of the files as a single bundle here (gzipped tar file).

The CHARMM input script to run this example will execute in a reasonable amount of time (1.5 hours on my 800 MHz G4 laptop for 5 trials). Running it on the CTBP Linux cluster will be faster if you wish. To run this script you execute the command
charmm ntrials=5 < pull_GoModel.inp > output_file
The input file for this example is given below:

* This CHARMM input script demonstrates the use of constant force (cf)
* and constant speed (steered-molecular dynamics, smd) pulling
* experiments on an all beta protein E2lip3 (PDB: 1qjo.pdb).
* The experiments explore the differences in mechanical stability and
* mechanical stress induced unfolding of this protein as a function of
* where the attachment is made. The calculations utilize the sequence-dependent
* Go-model of Karanicolas and Brooks and mirror the earlier study of
* Brockwell et al. (NSB, 10, 731-738 (2003)).
* This input script was developed following a template provide by
* Emanuele Paci from the University of Zurich in July 2004.
* The only input to this script is whether one is running an constant-force
* pulling calculation (Method = cf) or a constant speed pulling calculation
* (Method = smd) (the default is smd), where the cantilever is attached
* (Last = 80/41), and the number of pulling trials (Ntrials = x).
**
**
* Required files: go_[at]prot.top, go_[at]prot.param, go_[at]prot.seq,
* go_[at]prot.pdb
* where these files are from the MMTSB Go Model Server and the charmm
* variable prot (in [at]prot) is defined as prot = 1qjo
**
**
* Usage: charmm Method=[cf/smd] Last=[80/41] NTrials=[x] < pull_GoModel.inp > pull_GoModel.out
**
**
* Prepared by C.L. Brooks III, The Scripps Research Institute, July, 2004.
*

if @?Method eq 0 set Method = smd !set default method to smd
if @?Last eq 0 set Last = 80 !default is to pull from end
if @?Ntrials eq 0 set Ntrials = 1 !default number of runs is 1

SET SegName = prot ! Name of the domain
SET prot = 1qjo
SET Temp = 300 ! temperature for heatbath during pulling
SET TimeStep = 0.010 ! with Go models we can use a large timestep
SET Bias = 100 ! constant force in pN
SET Nsteps = 200000 ! Number of timesteps
SET First = 1
Calc Lmax = (@Last - @First) * 3.8 * 1.4 ! approximate maximum length of peptide
if Method eq smd SET Speed = 0.1 ! pulling speed with SMD (Angstroom/ps)

eten on ! Turn on the special interaction term for Go models

! Stream in the Go model parameters
STREAM "GO_@PROT.top"
STREAM "GO_@PROT.param"
STREAM "GO_@PROT.seq"

set cnt = 1
label dopull


! Set up a random seed
system "echo 'set iseed = ' `date +%H%M%S` > seed.stream"
stream seed.stream
system "rm seed.stream"
calc iseed = 2* @iseed + 1

! Read in the protein coordinates
OPEN UNIT 1 READ FORM NAME "GO_@PROT.pdb"
READ COOR PDB UNIT 1
CLOSE UNIT 1

ENERGY

SCALAR FBETA SET 0.1 SELECT all END ! Use friction coefficient to couple to Langevin
! heatbath.
SHAKE BOND TOL 1.0E-6 PARAM ! Use constraint to fix bonds

COOR DIST SELE (ATOM @SegName @First CA) END SELE (ATOM @SegName @Last CA) END
DEFINE nc SELE ((ATOM @SegName @First CA) .OR. (ATOM @SegName @Last CA)) END

OPEN WRITE FORMATTED UNIT 32 NAME @Method@Bias.@First-@Last_@cnt.rst
OPEN WRITE UNFORMATT UNIT 34 NAME @Method@Bias.@First-@Last_@cnt.trj
OPEN WRITE FORMATT UNIT 44 name @Method@Bias.@First-@Last_@cnt.juj

! { Pull with constant force }
if Method eq cf AFM @Method IUNJUJ 44 ALPHA @Bias SELE nc END XIMAX @Lmax
! { Pull with steered molecular dynamics }
if Method eq smd AFM @Method IUNJUJ 44 ALPHA @Bias BETA @Speed SELE nc END XIMAX @Lmax

DYNAMICS LEAP LANGEVIN START TIMESTEP @Timestep -
NSTEP @Nsteps NPRINT 100 IPRFRQ 50000 -
FIRSTT @Temp FINALT @Temp TWINDL -10.0 TWINDH 10.0 -
ICHECW 1 IEQFRQ 500 IASORS 1 IASVEL 1 -
NSAVC 5000 NSAVV 0 IUNVEL -1 -
IUNREA 31 IUNWRI 32 KUNIT -1 IUNCRD 34 -
INBFRQ 0 ILBFRQ 0 TBATH @Temp ECHECK 9999999999.0 ISEED @iseed

OPEN UNIT 1 WRITE FORM NAME @Method@Bias.@First-@Last_@cnt.pdb
WRITE COOR PDB UNIT 1
CLOSE UNIT 1

afm reset ! reset afm module for next trip through code

incr cnt by 1
if cnt le @Ntrials goto dopull

STOP


Results of multiple pulling "experiments".

1qjo_Go_smd.gif

Calculations carried out for multiple trials yield "traces" of the force required to strech the protein versus the distance from one point of connection to the next illustrate the qualitative difference that arises in the mechanical unfolding of a protein when it is streched from different positions. The resulst from these calculations are shown in the figure below, and illustrate that the protein unfolds with less force when pulled from the ends versus the force required when pulling from the center. What are the features of the protein topology that contribute to this behavior?

Representative streching trajectories

1-80.gif

Streching from N- and C-terminal ends

1-41.gif

Streching from N-terminus and resdue 41

Acknowledgement: This tutorial example was contributed by Emanuele Paci from the University of Leeds, England